Brave new methods

This year's SIG USE research symposium at ASIS&T Annual Meeting 2012 in Baltimore raised a number of interesting questions on the methods and approaches of information behaviour (needs, use, practices etc.) research. One, is of course precisely that. The continuos reference to information this and that objectifies information, and as Michael Olsson confessed, may actually imply that Brenda Dervin has been right all the time in emphasising verbing and refusing to see information as an object of study.

 

Another interesting point was the apparent raise of interest in making instead of mere use of information. Many of the discussed methods including photovoice (discussed by multiple presenters), expressive methods (Rachel Magee) and Barbara Wildemuth's proposal of using gerunds in coding interviews, Leanne Bowler's visual approach and Eric Meyers's use machinima (mentioning only a few) put emphasis on production and design of information to avoid both linguistic and other types of biases in gathering and analysing research data. Another apparent benefit of focussing on making is that making is obviously a process that tends to precede use (as I argued in the case of information literacy) and thus an obvious context of learning more about how and why people are using information as they happen to do.

 

A third take home message from the workshop was an urge for being slightly more creative in choosing research methods than we tend to be. Most of the people are using (traditional) surveys and interviews and only a handful engage themselves in using more creative approaches to collect and analyse data. Lisa Given showed some statistics in her keynote that even such really non-marginal approaches as theoretical research, model development and ethnography (believe or not) are surprisingly marginal in LIS literature. A first step to be critical of the mainstream methods is of course to realise that other methods exist, and to study interdisciplinary methods literature. The second one, is to be both creative and critical about what you are doing and assuming that you are doing. The third one is, as people were noting multiple times, is to get a supportive supervisor, get tenured (or a getting a permanent employment in continental Europe and Scandinavia) fast or to be very brave with your tenure committee.

Information Services and Digital Literacy provides an alternative perspective for understanding information services and digital literacy, and argues that a central problem in the age of the social web and the culture of participation is that we do not know the premises of how we know, and how ways of interacting with information affect our actions and their outcomes.

Read more

Taking Health Information Behaviour into Account: implications of a neglected element for success- ful implementation of consumer health technologies on older adults (HIBA) is an Academy of Finland funded research project at Åbo Akademi University.

Read more

ARKDIS project maps the implications and opportunities of the digitalisation of information and information work in the domain of archaeology and to develop and evaluate conceptual and practical methods and procedures for enhancing archaeological information work in the digitalised environment.

Read more